Newcastle Pizzeria

Welcome to Newcastle Pizzeria, a charming gem nestled on 505 Main St, Newcastle, CA. This delightful pizza restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for family dinners, evenings out with friends, or a casual date night. The rustic charm of its old building sets the stage for a culinary experience that stands out from the chain restaurants surrounding it.

At Newcastle Pizzeria, the focus is on crafting delicious, high-quality pizzas using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. The menu showcases a variety of specialty pizzas that cater to different palates, including the fan-favorite Sonoma, celebrated for its perfect balance of flavors and expertly cooked crust. Those seeking something hearty might delight in the If You Must pizza, a well-loved combination that impresses with its fresh toppings and satisfying blend of tastes. For a unique twist on tradition, you can't go wrong with the Newcastle Firefighters Favorite or Stella 2.0, both of which have been praised for their delightful flavor profiles and engaging textures.

And let’s not overlook the enticing appetizers! Guests rave about the fresh Meatball appetizer and vibrant Michigander salad that perfectly complement the pizza offerings. Dining here isn't just about food; it's about the entire experience, and the superb service makes a significant difference. Many reviews mention Truman, the personable bartender, whose humor and dedication elevate the ambience, leaving diners with unforgettable memories.

Newcastle Pizzeria also places a premium on catering to diverse dietary needs, providing standout options such as a gluten-free crust that many have deemed the best they've ever tasted. Add in the highly praised beet salad and wings, and it becomes clear why patrons can't help but return for more. The flavors burst from every dish, leaving mouths watering and cravings ignited long after the meal is over.

When it comes to your next pizza night, Newcastle Pizzeria should be your go-to destination. You’ll experience a unique blend of delightful pizzas, exceptional service, and a cozy environment that captures the heart of Newcastle. Prepare to indulge your senses and leave with a smile—as many have before you. Don’t miss the chance to explore this beloved local treasure. Make a reservation or simply drop by, but arrive early! It fills up fast for good reason!

For those seeking a truly authentic taste of Newcastle, visit Newcastle Pizzeria to create memories over great slices of pizza crafted with love and attention to detail.

• Traditional Margherita
• Veg-Head
• If You Must
• Sonoma
• Stella
• The Tuscany
• Stella 2.0
• Newcastle Firefighters Favorite
• Shanon's Favorite Bbq Chicken
• Aloha
• Sloane's Sweet & Sassy
• Jeri's Gluten Free Pizza